New Game +

Sort Total price, low to high Total price, high to low Listed most recently Listed longest Title Only listings that ship to the US Currency USD ($) AUD (A$) CAD (C$)

Pinny Shop 5 in stock at the shop

Pride New Game +

$26.00 Total to you

Item $20.00 Shipping $6.00 to the US

eBay Lot of 4 106 days listed · 2026-07-21

Pinny Penny Arcade PAX 2019 Pride Pin Set Game Critically Queer LGBTQ pins

~$11.05 This pin's share

Lot total $43.00 Item $35.00 Shipping $8.00 to Seattle, WA

with 3 other pins

In this lot · $43.00 total

• Critically Queer~$14.54
• New Game + (this pin)~$11.05
• Gaytroller~$8.93
• Super Cutie~$8.48

Each share splits the listed total by the pins' calculated prices, so a pricier pin carries more of it.

Lots don't set this pin's price.

Re-verify

Pinny Shop Lot of 4 1 in stock at the shop

Pride

~$15.42 This pin's share

Lot total $60.00 Item $60.00 Shipping $0.00 to Seattle, WA

with 3 other pins

In this lot · $60.00 total

• Critically Queer~$20.29
• New Game + (this pin)~$15.42
• Gaytroller~$12.46
• Super Cutie~$11.83

Each share splits the listed total by the pins' calculated prices, so a pricier pin carries more of it.

Lots don't set this pin's price.

Total Price is what a buyer actually pays: item price + shipping + marketplace fees (Mercari charges buyers a 3.6% Buyer Protection fee on the item + shipping; eBay has no buyer fee). Pinny Shop ships free on US orders over $59, adds a flat $6 below that, and charges a flat $15 to Australia and Canada. Tax is not included. eBay shipping is what that country's eBay quotes, for the currency you pick: to Seattle, WA for USD, to Melbourne, VIC for AUD, to Vancouver, BC for CAD. When a listing is not offered in that country, its total is shown to another, and says so. The flags on a listing are the countries it is offered in. Mercari ships within the US only. Shipping may differ for other locations. A listing with no shipping figure is one we have not been able to retrieve yet. A lot holds several pins for one price. Its share for this pin splits the lot total by each pin's calculated price; lots are shown here but never set the calculated or lowest price, since one pin can't be bought out of a lot.

Probably sold

eBay Lot of 3 Sold in a lot of 3 · 2026-11-01 · after 1 day

Pinny Arcade PAX 2019 Pride Gaming Pin Set MISSING 1 Super Cutie

~$12.23 This pin's share of the sale

Lot total paid $31.50 Not counted in the calculated price

with 2 other pins

In this lot · $31.50 total

• New Game + (this pin)~$12.23
• Gaytroller~$9.88
• Super Cutie~$9.39

Each share splits the sold total by the pins' calculated prices, so a pricier pin carries more of it.

Pinny Shop Probably sold · 2026-10-15

Pride New Game +

$26.00 Total paid

Item $20.00 Shipping $6.00 to the US

eBay Lot of 4 Probably sold in a lot of 4 · 2026-07-21 · after 259 days

Pinny Penny Arcade PAX 2019 Pride Pin Set Game Critically Queer LGBTQ pins

~$16.19 This pin's share of the sale

Lot total paid $63.00 Not counted in the calculated price

with 3 other pins

In this lot · $63.00 total

• Critically Queer~$21.30
• New Game + (this pin)~$16.19
• Gaytroller~$13.08
• Super Cutie~$12.43

Each share splits the sold total by the pins' calculated prices, so a pricier pin carries more of it.

Pinny Shop Lot of 4 Probably sold in a lot of 4 · 2025-11-18

Pride

~$15.42 This pin's share of the sale

Lot total paid $60.00 Not counted in the calculated price

with 3 other pins

In this lot · $60.00 total

• Critically Queer~$20.29
• New Game + (this pin)~$15.42
• Gaytroller~$12.46
• Super Cutie~$11.83

Each share splits the sold total by the pins' calculated prices, so a pricier pin carries more of it.

Sold is the marketplace's own record: Mercari's sold listings, and eBay's count of units sold on a listing we tracked. Probably sold is inferred: an eBay listing that ended before we could ask eBay about it, and disappeared and stayed gone — except one that ended exactly at the end of a listing period (7 days, or a multiple of 30), which most likely just was not relisted — or a drop in Pinny Shop's stock, at that day's price. A sale in a lot is several pins sold for one price; this pin's share splits it by the pins' calculated prices, and it is not counted in the calculated price.